| Nov 13, 2026 | Case: 25-CT-015343 | Judge Castor |
| Facts: | The defendant was involved in a traffic crash. Officers noticed an odor of alcohol, slurred speech, a flushed face, and red/watery eyes. The defendant was taken to the hospital. At the hospital, the officer had him perform the HGN (eye test), finger to nose, palm pat, and hand coordination exercises. The defendant was arrested for DUI at the hospital and later refused a blood test. | |
| Defense: | The defendant was not the at fault driver. He was actually the one who got rear ended. In addition, it was determined that the driver who hit him was DUI. At the hospital, with no nurses around, this officer was taking medical wires out of the defendant's body so he could do the finger nose and other exorcises. He had no idea what medical wires he was removing. It was absolutely ridiculous and captured on tape. The firm filed a motion to suppress the refusal to give blood. In our motion, we set forth that the officer did not determine if a breath test was impactable or impossible pursuant to Florida Statutes. The Judge granted the motion and threw out the refusal to submit to a blood test. After several negotiations, the State Dismissed the DUI. | |
| Result: | The DUI was dismissed. | |
